I don’t hate God because my son died. That might be surprising to some and others probably don’t understand that at all, but that’s how it is for me.
I do believe that there is a loving, creative force at the center of this Universe. Life tends to flourish here. Lichens and mosses sprout on rocks. Bacteria thrives in the most harsh conditions. Stars ignite into brilliance at the farthest reaches of this and countless other galaxies.
The way a seed grips the soil around it and sips water with tiny roots, that is God. The way objects in motion tend to stay in motion unless another force acts on that object, that is God. That love can blaze into existence with a shared moment or secret touch, that, of course, is God, too.
But if there is a God, how could something like this happen to people like us? That’s the question, right? Not for me. I don’t ask that question. I don’t think God had anything to do with what happened to Silas. We are creatures of this World, this Earth. Laws of Nature dictate the way things operate. Gravity pulls us to the planet and whirls us around the sun. Food has taste, eyes can see. I am confident that tomorrow is ahead of me and that the past slides into memory with every second that goes by.
In this world there is death. For everyone I know, someday, there is death. It is a constant effort to remain alive. We must eat and breathe, we must drink lots of water to keep our systems and organs functioning. Our minds need art and words and interaction to stay healthy and whole. Our souls need love and truth, beauty, grace, dreams and hopes to stay alive.
God is the fountain from which all of those things flow. But I do not believe in a Tinker God. I do not see a tiny precise hand rearranging the World for maximum benefit and correctness. Bad shit happens. Unintended consequences are par for this enormous course. Perhaps there are magic and miracles happening out there. If so, they are rare and special. So was Silas, but unfortunately that just doesn’t matter. Every child is rare and special. The sad, brutal truth is that no species on the planet has 100% reproductive success.
This all sounds so clinical, I know. But that’s not at all how I feel about this, about Silas dying, about our life denied. It is raw and visceral and impossibly immediate. The extreme absence of my son is brutally palpable.
The fact is, I know this was not supposed to happen. It never is, for any parent. It is a flaw in the way the World operates, but there are so many flaws, so many errors in the way people treat one another. Injustice, terror, fear, poverty, destruction, disease, these are all errors in this World and when I compare the sadness to the joy the only conclusion I can come to is that God can’t be happy about any of this, either.
I do not believe that we are being taught a lesson by God. I do not believe that Silas died for ‘a reason’. Everything would always be better if he had lived and if he was with us today.
I believe God thinks so, too. I believe that God is old and deep and the source of love, light and all the planes of reality in this Universe, but I do not believe that God is perfect. I think the Universe itself yearns for an existence where such things did not happen, ever.
Perhaps that is why we are here. Maybe our role in this Universe is to imagine it such that mothers always give birth to perfect, healthy children; that Death appears only at the far end of long, beautiful lives and is welcomed as a respite from pain; that illness is always overcome; that love always triumphs over hate; that peace and grace and joy and laughter always soothes, always quiets our volatile souls.
Missing Silas makes me ache even more for all the lost children, all the death and horror in this world. I’m not mad at God for what happened to my son, but I am so terribly sad about it.
I think God is, too.

20 comments
Comments feed for this article
December 23, 2008 at 12:11 am
Sally
Chris this is a beautiful post. I’m not religious at all, but you managed to sum up my half-baked ideas about relgion and about whatever sort of “god” may be out there much more eloquently than I ever could. I’m mad at the professionals who failed us, but sad at the universe/god/whatever who let this happen. The madness and anger can come and go, but the sadness is with me every step I take.
Oh, and I for one will never think our babies died for a “reason”. What reason could there possibly be for taking healthy babies from healthy mothers at the end of healthy pregnancies? And I don’t believe that they are in a “better place”, either. For what better place is there for a child, a tiny baby at that, here on earth with their loving mummies and daddies? Our babies might be in a beautiful place, but it is second best in my opinion.
Thinking of you guys as we approach the end of this very bittersweet year for us all xo
December 23, 2008 at 9:18 am
Ezra's Mommy
This is a beautiful post indeed. And summed up what I’ve not quite been able to articulate myself, particularly when faced with the folks that try to explain it away with ‘God knows best’ or ‘we can’t question God’s decisions’. I’ve never believed in a God that would “decide” to take a baby away from his loving parents – it was never my understanding of God before this, and it certainly can’t be now. Thank you for this, it was exactly what I needed today.
December 23, 2008 at 9:46 am
keith
incredible chris. thanks.
December 23, 2008 at 11:26 am
Kristina
Even when I try to suppress them, you still manage to bring tears to my eyes with your writing. Beautiful, as always.
((HUGS))
December 23, 2008 at 11:34 am
Sheila
So beautiful. It makes sense and feels true… you have an old-soul wisdom that allows you to see clearly in the darkness and you are so gifted for being able to articulate something that almost transcends words. Thanks for always being so lucid and honest and for having the courage to share your thoughts and emotions, I believe you are helping many people. Sending love your way always.
December 23, 2008 at 11:37 am
Brad
You have always had a gift with words Chris. This sums up many things that I have been thinking as well. Thank you.
December 23, 2008 at 12:10 pm
mrs.spit
I remember the friend who took my hand and said “God is weeping with you, you know.”
I’m sorry that Silas isn’t here with you. I’m sorry that death and evil win in this world.
December 23, 2008 at 3:47 pm
Amy
I am a stranger, just a reader. This post encapsulates so much. I can’t really respond to it; I just want to copy and paste it and put it somewhere where I can read it over and over again. You stare straight into the face of the greatest dilemma that we human beings face, and your response is soulful, aching, compassionate, heartbreaking, and yet not without hope. Although you never chose, and never wanted, the role that you are now playing, you and your wife have so much to teach us all.
December 23, 2008 at 9:35 pm
mom
chris,,,,if there is indeed a god he has instilled in you the beauty of poetic language….your blog tonight was beyond touching ….deep and hopeful in a way ……you and lani have so much love to give and we feel it all the time. your baby is somewhere out there grasping onto the love his parents have for him…..and he will forever be in all our hearts.
we love you and will wrap ourselves around your insights….written in beauty and light…
December 24, 2008 at 11:56 am
Ezra's Daddy
Well said Chris. I enjoy your blog, and agree with what you said about not blaming God. Our son died in utero in August after an 8-month pregnancy, and he was born the next day. I never blamed anything or anyone (including God) for it. If anything, I blamed the blood clot in the placenta that cut off his oxygen, but I always focused on him not being here physically, not why it happened. When I first saw him and held him, I said that I was looking at the face of God.
I pray that no one else has to experience the feelings that come from helping your wife give birth to a son that has already died. Yet at the same time, the profound joy that came with seeing Ezra for the first time– mixed with profound despair and sorrow over losing him– reminded me that there is a universal force out there. I am not particularly religious, although I am observing all of the season’s holidays, go figure (holidays are difficult this year). But since I stared into the face of God in August, and buried my son several days later, I have become a far more spiritual person. In such a short time, my little man has given me so much. He has taught me how to love and care about others. He has taught me about what is really important. Although he is not here physically, his spirit is sitting beside me as I write this comment to you.
Best to you as we, the broken parents of lost babies, take this journey together.
December 24, 2008 at 12:42 pm
Monique
Beautiful, Chris. My sentiments exactly – I refuse to believe our children died for any reason other than random, bad things happen sometimes. I found once I stopped asking “Why” (why me more percisely), I was able to process Sam’s death a little better. Why not me is the answer I’ve come to. I am so sorry Silas is not here with you and Lani.
December 24, 2008 at 1:50 pm
mammaliza
thank you chris. i am left with tears. i want to believe these truths that you write. but my anger has been directed at god, i guess because there’s no other force for me to blame and i have so much anger. i have told god to fuck off so many times. i felt so connected and blessed, like my prayers were finally answered by whatever image of god i had, that now i just feel so completely betrayed. yet i hold your words as truth. thank you for this beautiful powerful post.
December 24, 2008 at 2:07 pm
Gal
Magnificent… I agree. Thank you.
December 24, 2008 at 2:08 pm
Gal
One more thing: I’ve thought often in the months since my daughter’s death that God is perfect in this moment because God is there for me to feel anger at if that is what I need, and also there to feel comfort from when that is what I need instead.
December 24, 2008 at 4:25 pm
Cassidy
This is brilliant.
December 26, 2008 at 12:21 pm
Shuman
Morning, Chris. Your words are amazing and I don’t know how you get them to flow the way you do but that is one of your many special talents. I agree with everything you said above but I couldn’t articulate it until you did.
December 27, 2008 at 5:21 pm
robin
That was very beautiful and so personal. Thank you, Chris.
Much love,
Robin
December 27, 2008 at 9:48 pm
Rachel
Beautiful. Perfect. And yes, so sad : (
xxx
December 29, 2008 at 10:24 pm
B
Amen.
January 1, 2009 at 11:23 pm
Kristen
You said this so beautifully and articulated perfectly what I have so many times tried to explain to people about my daughter’s death and many other things. Thank you. I am so sorry for your loss, my heart aches for you and I pray that you find peace and comfort in the arms of God.